(Close Window)
Topic: The most perfect coin trick
Message: Posted by: Brad Burt (May 20, 2006 10:07PM)
I was sitting working on my basics. Always the basics. And, for some reason I was suddenly engaged in attempting to think of the one coin routine that I had seen over the years that I thought was the most perfect, the most magical of all coin routines.

After a bit of thought I once again decided that it was a routine by David Roth. I was privledged years ago to spend a couple of nights at the Magic Castle when David was there for his first performing run. Here was the coin ledgend and a bunch of us went up to see him. He proved to be actually better than the hype. Although I saw him work three times I only remember one routine: The Tuning Fork. To this day, it remains the single best conceived and executed piece of coin magic I have witnessed.

Why is that? What struck me about it? The Finale. Here was a wizard that actually DID what a Wizard would do! He took sound and via the modality of some kind of otherworldly Alchemy David opened his hand and out came real money that I would have sworn was not there a moment ago. It is a conceptually perfect routine. There is even a kind odd sense to the whole thing. Sound captured in a glass is poured into a hand ... and ... then ... money magically appears.

There are also the props used. Even the props seem magical. A tuning fork has always seemed an arcane instrument to me. A glass to replace the beakers and flasks of a long gone laboratoria. The wizard himself impish and sure of his ability to fool us with all the 'dressing' that was used to lull us into thinking that he was a mere jongler from centuries past. Good, maybe even brilliant manipulations to throw us off. To fool us into thinking that he wasn't real, so that we wouldn't catch on until later: Mr Roth was the real deal. He could turn air into coin. This I think was Roth's real magic those nights. I was left for over 30 years with the conviction that real magic had happened.

Maybe you have a coin routine that has effected you in similar fashion and can explain why? What was it about it that made you feel magic took place. Real magic. What lasted with you? Best,
Message: Posted by: Nathan Kranzo (May 20, 2006 10:21PM)
Wow Brad!

Both you and David have inspired me! Thanks for that.

All the best,

Kranzo
Message: Posted by: Frankm6 (May 21, 2006 12:02AM)
[quote]
On 2006-05-20 23:07, BradBurt wrote:
The Tuning Fork. To this day, it remains the single best conceived and executed piece of coin magic I have witnessed.

[/quote]

I have sumitted, in the past, that the Tuning Fork is the best close up trick I've ever seen. Beyond magic, somehow emotional, beautiful... Brad you are right as rain.
Message: Posted by: Brad Burt (May 21, 2006 08:45PM)
Frankm6:

Yes! The funny thing is this...I am positive that if I had first read the effect in a book I would NOT have realized how good the routine was. I mean break it down and basically it is this: Some coins appear in a magicians hand. But, like a lot of the best tricks in magic you have to SEE that bloody thing to appreciate just how good it is.

Another trick like this is somewhat more mundane, but illustrates this further: Quinella by Harry Loranye. This is nothing more than the old trick where a selected card turns instantly face up when the deck is dropped on to the table. The difference is that in Quinella it happens twice. This is one of those tricks that is almost over before you start and YET it just simply KILLS laymen! In fact the trick is so strong it is almost eerie to me to this day and I've been doing it for over 30 years. Two cards picked and put back in the deck. Cut the deck and let fall to table first card is there now face up. Repeat with other half of deck.

Who would have thought? I originally did it because frankly it seemed easy! I was just looking for a quick simple thing to add to my small bag of tricks.

To this day it seems the best things I do are some of the simplest. Peter Rabbit, Tenkai Pennies, Quinella. Don't you love magic? Best,
Message: Posted by: landmark (May 21, 2006 10:35PM)
David Roth's Funnel has got to be my favorite coin routine! The final show of small coins turning back into normal size coins visibly is just stunning to me. A wonderful premise carried through to its (il)logical conclusion!

Jack Shalom
Message: Posted by: phread (May 22, 2006 10:31AM)
I agree about the tuning fork!...stone henge assembly...wild coin...the only routine of david roth's that is not very good is chink a chink, simply the most obvious mechanics...

dug
Message: Posted by: Dan LeFay (May 22, 2006 12:23PM)
I think Paul Harris' Twilight has a lot of potential. The pure effect where the mirror-image becomes real (seen from the right angle) is Lewis Carroll at its best.
Paul's original routine does not fit my needs too good. But there are other possibilities.

Most magical experience I've ever had though remains Armando Lucero's Coin Menagerie. Describing it in words is completely useless. It has to be seen and be savoured.