(Close Window)
Topic: Best inexpensive reel?
Message: Posted by: George Ledo (Sep 3, 2020 12:02PM)
Not sure where to post this, but I'm looking for a really good inexpensive reel, as in $20 - $30. I'm going to need a quantity of them.

Any thoughts?
Message: Posted by: David Todd (Sep 3, 2020 06:03PM)
Hi, George -

I've been looking for an inexpensive reel , too. (to use for the silk through mic stand/cane/etc.) I have ordered the one from PropDog in the U.K. I should have it by tomorrow or early next week. (after the Labor Day holiday on Monday). I'll let you know what I think. It has good reviews.



Note the price is $38.56 for non-EU customers. So that means for ordering it from U.S.A. it is $38.56 , plus shipping (which in my case was $3.07 from the U.K. to east coast of U.S.A. for basic airmail shipping 5 - 9 business days. If you ask for expedited shipping it will be more.)

Notice PropDog's guarantee: [i]"If for any reason you decide that you are not happy with this reel, simply send it back and we'll give you a full refund!"[/i]
Message: Posted by: Bill Hegbli (Sep 3, 2020 07:05PM)
Daytona Magic has finger reels for $15.

Locking Reels I have, were never cheap.

Without knowing the use, it is impossible to give you assistance.

I have a powerful finger ring locking reel, but it would be very expensive, and it large 2.5 inches in diameter, and weighs about 2 pounds.

I also have some P&L silk reels that I am attempting to repair with new lines.
Message: Posted by: Harry Murphy (Sep 4, 2020 11:13AM)
George, check out Staples for name badge reels. They are not super quiet but will work for Serpentine Silk, Silk through mike stand, and the like. Michael Ammar uses (and sells) them in his lectures.


IDwholesaler has versions too. They are sold in bulk.


A stronger reel would be the old Key holder reel:

Good luck!
Message: Posted by: George Ledo (Sep 8, 2020 06:57PM)
Thank you all. Good suggestions there.
Message: Posted by: Magic Mark (Dec 24, 2020 09:32PM)
I ordered a PropDog Reel Revolution, it arrived yesterday. After opening the package I tested the reel by pulling out about 6” of line and gently let it pull back in. Then I pulled out about 12-15” of line and to my surprise, it wouldn’t retract. Jiggling the line did nothing, it wouldn’t retract. I disassembled the two halves of the case, could not see anything that was obviously broken, and simply assumed it was possibly wound on the wheel incorrectly from the factory. I wound the line back around the wheel, added another turn to give it some tension, and reassembled the case. When I tried pulling out 15” or so of line the same thing happened, it would not retract.

I emailed PropDog yesterday but I guess they must have taken Christmas Eve off (which is completely understandable), they did not reply today. I am confident that they’ll make it right, but disappointed that I waited 2 weeks only to receive a defective reel and that, with the revised lockdowns, I may have to wait even longer for a replacement.

It seems there is a market for a really high quality reel that is quiet and built with supreme reliability. I miss the days when you could get a brand new Paul Diamond reel.

Message: Posted by: Bill Hegbli (Dec 24, 2020 10:17PM)
Magic Mark, did the reel come with instruction? Did you read or view them before doing what your described?

The number one rule with any reels is that you never let the line fly back on it own without something attached to the line.

Even if you were holding the line, it could have caused damage, the line getting caught or not setting correctly.

You should not have opened the reel, that could have caused problems a well, and therefore, any warranty void.
Message: Posted by: Magic Mark (Dec 24, 2020 10:44PM)
I did not let the line snap back on its own. I described what I did in an accurate fashion because I suspected someone would assume I did something careless. I did not.

As for taking the reel apart, I did nothing more than what is shown in this video, which I watched (again) before disassembling the top half of the reel. That was all I disassembled, I removed the top half and wound the loose line back around the wheel and put the top back on and secured it with the screw.


Message: Posted by: Bill Hegbli (Dec 29, 2020 09:26PM)
Here is the cheapest reel available. It is called the Bill Snatcher, a gag item novelty. $3.99

If you think the line is to thick, then you have to replace the one in the reel. It is a little difficult to get it apart, but possible with your fingernails.

Message: Posted by: Magic Mark (Dec 30, 2020 12:19AM)
PropDog employees were on Holiday through Monday. They responded today and are sending a replacement reel. They are not requiring me to return the broken reel. Excellent customer service.