Lots of good stuff listed. I will add "Creation" By Paul Harris. AOA #1.

It leaves people in awe!

A simple transpostion using a duplicate works wonders.

I've posted this before, but I'd have to say the Anywhere Card... Final selection pulled out of the Bicycle card case "card back" side (held with lower portion of wrapper), that a spectator was holding... People believe the card just formed from the case...

Tricks that happen when they can't believe it happened. Simple card Transposition by Eddie Fechter.
Jay

I think a coin that they have marked, out of their pocket, given to you and they put into a ball of string into a nest of box's is good.

Also the unbroken match is a very good trick to get them to think "What was I smoking..."

The two effects that I have gotten the biggest wow effect after doing are Invisible Deck and Twisting arm illusion. I have had people run out of the room after the invisible deck. I have others but those are two that I do on a very regular basis.

Paramount by Aldo Columbini and Deep Astonishment by Paul Harris.

I like how you guys talk about stoners like they aren't even human. DA is a good effect but it will lose their attention. Try using DA with a Card Under Box routine.

Lee

Yada, yada, yada!!! I think you guys all forgot NFW, anyone I perform this for really does say the name out loud, it leaves them astounded.

alan

NFW?

Does NFW really get you such reactions? I may have to try it... I tend to get good
"NFW" reaction with twisting the aces, because for the last ace, I tend to bend the cards, and ask the spectator to "snap" them back to straight, and show that they just turned the ace of spades over magically.

Healed and Sealed can trick done right would take my vote.
Thank you and God bless

Years and YEARS ago, there was a beer commerical featuring John Scarne. (I can't remember the brand.) At the end of the commercial, John showed the top card of the deck, put it face down on the table and put the glass of beer on top of it. Then he showed the next card in the deck, and put it face down on top of the glass. Snap of the fingers and the cards changed places. Took me a day or two to figure out [a] way of doing the trick... took me considerably longer to figure out a way to rig a deck up so I could do that trick and not keep using the same cards! However, it [never] fails to get a 'woah, dude' from people!

mai, do you have a method for this?

Reality Twister...I get crazy reactions from that one. We made our own BIC pens and it works great.

Perform the sponges on them.

Cigarette thru Quarter.

The Thought Transmitter.

The Brainwave Deck.

xPert coin bend

landmark

My friend has a form of Out of This World that can be done with a shuffled deck, and it's not the Hinstien shuffle.

I think that levitations get the "wow" reaction.

Jay Sankey's "In A Flash" always makes their jaws drop.