While the MagicCafe is a place for Magicians to help Magicians, we welcome mentalists to take part in discussions involving their craft. For this reason, we have two forums specifically for those discussions. This forum, "Penny For Your Thoughts" is for the general discussion of mentalism and mentalism related topics. No methods may be discussed here however. The second forum, "Inner Thoughts" is only available after reaching 50 legitimate posts. It is here that more in depth discussions, which may include methods, can be held. Posts with exposure or leading to exposure will be removed from the Penny forum.

Dave, thank you for posting this. Hopefully it will go some way to avoiding exposure in the searchable 'penny' forum.

Thank you for clarifying these guidelines. The rules for posting in penny and inner thoughts are hopefully more clear to all now.

May also be worth mentioning that we also have Mentally Speaking for product reviews although many reviews are best posted in Inner Thoughts.

Mark

Thanks Dave...

In this section:
we do not ask how something is done that we've seen
though we do ask for book or dvd references

we do not mention by name techniques and methods
though we do downstairs, in inner thoughts

we introduce ourselves and are open and honest with each other
we talk about mentalism in general terms up here, and more indepth downstairs
we report posts that break the forum rules and posting guidelines
we try to all get along!

Oh Well,
my topic is locked.
I surely understand these guidelines and want to stick to them (I love the art!), but it's a little bit hard to "reach" 50 Post for the "inner entrance". I have enough knowledge to develop my routines but when I have a question I can't post it cause there is this "50 posts rule" I don't want to post 50 rubbish answers just to go there. I mainly just read posts and when there is something interesting on the Café, I grab an old book, buy a new one and I don't have to post irrelvant things...so how to write 50 posts, when I'm not allowed to
hach, let's see...

With respect Mysteryos, I think you're missing the point of this community. If you say you are "have enough knowledge" and "live the art", the surely you'd have opinions and thoughts to share in some of the general topics here in Penny? Asking questions and receiving help is only one part of what members here do. We have plenty of topics where you could share your own perspectives or experiences with someone else, as well as a large number of less serious threads where no deep knowledge is required.

I realise new members don't have a lot of advice or answers to give, but if you're reading Penny a lot, you should have found many places where you could post that aren't affected by your level of experience. Don't be afraid to talk to us. Chances are that the members here won't answer your questions anyway if we haven't learned enough about through your posts. Hanging back and dreaming of hitting 50 posts doesn't help you get there, nor does it let us get to know you.

Hey C.J.
I'm sorry, I didn't want to sound arrogant - english is not my native language and its sometime a little bit hard to write whats on my mind and then I sound rude when I don't want to. That's right, I will search for some topics and try to give some answers or opinions on posts. I really didn't reflect my post above, I was just a little bit upset because my Topic was locked immediately and I only asked for some help on a "Switch" not for exposing methods(maybe a good book or a PM)...

But Yeah you are right, let's see if I could finde some good penny topics

Thx!

Mary Moder in 'New Arrivals' suggested I should call here

So an introduction, my name is Kevin, I come from Ireland and I am currently studying for the Ministry.

Like all ministers we are called upon now again for a party piece. A wedding breakfast, schools and care homes would probably be the most common. Most of my fellow students can hold a note and have found 3 or 4 songs that suit them. As I said elsewhere my voice is like 'the mating call of a rusty file!' That's part of the reason I've ended up here. I'm hoping that over the next period I can put together a small collection of magic effects that on special occasions I can offer as my party piece. I'm thinking mentalist and mathmagic. When visiting my old school I did a magic square and amazed even myself.

So, up front, you'll see I'm not a professional, or even semi-professional magican and I don't intend to go down that road all I'm really interested in is putting together a few routines that will help me move closer to people. I trust you can welcome me on that basis and possibly offer your advice

Kah22, by Ministry do you mean Christian ministry? There are some topics that might be insightful regarding mentalism and magic under the "Fellowship of Christian Magicians" and "the Good News" sections on the main page. Hope that helps...

Thanks. Yes, I hope to become a Catholic priest.

How does the Café differentiate between "legitimate" and "not legitimate" posts?

Is this the reason why the term "billet" should not be used in shows? So that nobody googles it and finds his/her way to threads about billets?

Thanks Dave

HI, My name is Elisha and I am an aspiring mentalist. I think that most people, at least in my experience, will immediately smell foul when you say the word b****t. If you say, "write someone's name on this b****t", they will ask you what a b****t is, what a b****t does, who created the idea of a b****t, and other difficult questions. When I first read practical mental magic I had to google what a b****t was.