The Magic Cafe Forum Index » » Puzzle me this... » » Triangles puzzle (0 Likes) Nir Dahan Inner circle Munich, Germany 1390 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 02:31 am 0 It's been a long time since I posted here. Here is a puzzle that can be solved by 9th graders, but can cause some confusion with some people. Assuming a triangle is defined by 6 characteristics- 3 lengths of sides and 3 angles, can there be 2 triangles that have 5 of the 6 categories equal to one another, but still not be identical triangles? If so, find those triangles. If not, prove it cant be so. Have fun, Nir Adventures in ASIC digital design Scott Cram Inner circle 2677 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 11:18 am 0 If you're just defining a triangle as 3 lengths of sides and 3 angles, then I can draw you a million such triangles as you suggest. If instead, you define a triangle as a closed figure with three sides, and three internal angles that sum to 180 degrees, then the puzzle becomes a little trickier. Grey Matters:Blog|Videos|Mental Gym|Presentation|Store Nir Dahan Inner circle Munich, Germany 1390 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 12:28 pm 0 Scott - 3 internal angles and a euclidian surface - all angles sum to 180 degrees. No tricks. Adventures in ASIC digital design Jonathan Townsend Eternal Order Ossining, NY 27097 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 12:53 pm 0 For some reason I'm getting stuck on the ASA and SAS proofs of similarity. Taking them as ASASAS or SASASA, working around one triangle, I don't see how losing one of the letters can give you a non congurent triangle. Then again I am at work at the moment. ...to all the coins I've dropped here Nir Dahan Inner circle Munich, Germany 1390 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 01:34 pm 0 Jonathan, First, thanks for clarifying the terminology - English is not my native language. But you have some fallacy in your "proof". Think again. Nir Adventures in ASIC digital design landmark Inner circle within a triangle 4923 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 05:15 pm 0 Imagine two triangles: triangle ABC with opposite sides a, b, and c; and triangle A'B'C', with opposite sides a', b', and c'. Now imagine angle A = A', B=B', and C=C'. Also imagine side AC = side B'C', and side BC = side A'B'. Thus there are five corresponding equalities. Yet these two triangles are not necessarily identical. A bit hard to explain without a diagram, but draw the above and you'll see what I mean. Jack Shalom Click here to get Gerald Deutsch's Perverse Magic: The First Sixteen Years All proceeds to Open Heart Magic charity. Nir Dahan Inner circle Munich, Germany 1390 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 06:31 pm 0 Jack, There is a "family" of such triangles that will fullfill these conditions. Can you find them? Nir Adventures in ASIC digital design landmark Inner circle within a triangle 4923 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 09:54 pm 0 Here's a step towards defining a family: imagine two right triangles. The first triangle has sides a, b, and hypotenuse c; the second triangle has sides b, c, and hypotenuse d. If these two triangles are similar, they will fulfill the requirements of the problem. The triangles are similar if b/a = c/b. Then, using Pythagorean theorem, you can conclude that the two triangles are similar when b exponent 4 equals a exponent 4 + a exponent 2 * b exponent 2. Whether this has real solutions, I'm not sure. If there are real solutions to the above, then you could probably extend this to non-right triangles using the Law of Cosines, rather than the Pythagorean theorem to set up the needed relationships amongst the sides. Am I getting close? Jack Click here to get Gerald Deutsch's Perverse Magic: The First Sixteen Years All proceeds to Open Heart Magic charity. magicgeorge Inner circle Belfast 4299 Posts  Posted: Feb 6, 2004 11:34 pm 0 Because 5 characteristics have to be equal, either all the angles are the same or all the sides are the same. If the sides were the same, they would be the same triangle (ie 6 would match). That means all the angles are the same. Therefore, the triangles will be similair triangles (ie one of the triangles is a scaled up/down version of the other). Consider a triangle with sides of lengths x,y and z. (Starting with smallest). Because they're identical triangles, the other will have lengths of kx, ky, and kz, where k is a constant. To fit the boundaries of Nir's puzzle, kx=y and ky=z. In triangle x,y,z kx=y ky=z and x+y>z z=k sqr times x x+kx>ksqr x 1+k>k squared or 1>k(k-1) Therefore k is between 1 and 2? K being greater than one, because if it was a fraction, then the second triangle would be smaller. If the second was smaller, we would swap triangles and k would be greater than 1 (i.e. k =1/2 it's same as saying k=2 for the other triangle). I've simply used 2 via substitution, there's a more exact number if you want to find it by solving 1=k(k-1). Let's try 1.5. a 4,6,9 triangle and a 6,9,13.5. Fit the credentials. And no pythag. or trig in sight. George edit:k is less than 1.618 . Therefore answer in full is any triangle with side x,kx and k sqr x and another triangle kx,ksqr x and k cubed x. will work for values where 10, k>0 and of course k<>1. Construct the other triangle to be kx, x and x/k. /Tomas Nir Dahan Inner circle Munich, Germany 1390 Posts  Posted: Feb 9, 2004 02:11 pm 0 Tomas you got it right... Adventures in ASIC digital design magicgeorge Inner circle Belfast 4299 Posts  Posted: Feb 9, 2004 03:08 pm 0 Hey, I got it right too. My answer works and also includes the parameters for k. Tomas's answer is just a different way of saying the same thing (see edit in second post) Magician Belfast Dave Le Fevre Inner circle UK 1649 Posts  Posted: Feb 15, 2004 05:42 am 0 Quote:On 2004-02-07 11:15, magicgeorge wrote: P.S. how do I do a squared sign on here? I have a Word document of such odd characters, some of which I know how to create (by Ctrl + Alt + whatever), and the rest of which I simply copy'n'paste. There are superfixes in there, but when I copy'n'paste them into a post reply window here, they lose their superfix property. (And I don't know how to create them.) Dave The Ozzy Osbourne of the 34x27 dlhoyt Regular user 176 Posts  Posted: Feb 15, 2004 08:35 pm 0 Quote:P.S. how do I do a squared sign on here? k^2 = "k squared" The Magic Cafe Forum Index » » Puzzle me this... » » Triangles puzzle (0 Likes)
 The views and comments expressed on The Magic Café are not necessarily those of The Magic Café, Steve Brooks, or Steve Brooks Magic. > Privacy Statement <   