|
|
|||
| Go to page [Previous] 1~2 | ||||||||||
|
Nathan Alexander Inner circle 2249 Posts
|
Or, "chat can do this, but for whatever reason I always like this sites answers better... maybe because I'm old and it just looks cool, ha"
I just shrug it off. That said, the point is taken and pretty much true about defaulting to chat. But not everyone. |
|||||||||
|
Chaz93 Inner circle Texas 2046 Posts
|
And to be fair, I don't hate this concept at all. I actually built my own web app that does something similar for personal use.
But for the reasons I mentioned above, I eventually found that while the technology is cool and it's a lot of fun to play with, I don't think it's particularly viable as a performance piece. All it takes is one person at the table pulling out their phone, Googling “personality reading for the name Joe,” and then saying, “Okay, do me next I have a name and meaning loaded up.” At that point I'm thinking, “Welp... time to pivot.” My critique isn't really of the app or the concept itself. It's the reliance on a specific website as part of the experience. It's going to happen that a spectator types in a name in google or ai or whatever and expects you to be able to give them a personality reading if you've demonstrated you could do that. The glaring red flag comes in because you cannot, unless they go to a specific website. This is the very reason that I decided that as fun as it was to build and play with a similar app it was something that wouldn't really get performed by me. In 2026, I think it's becoming less and less natural for people to seek out a specific website to accomplish a simple task, because of the way the modern internet has changed. Increasingly, people expect to be able to just ask Google, ChatGPT, or another general-purpose AI to do something for them. That's the vulnerability I see with this type of app magic. The technology can be genuinely cool and the effect can be genuinely entertaining, but if the spectator can immediately reproduce the underlying experience themselves with whatever happens to be on their phone, I think that's something a performer has to account for. |
|||||||||
|
PatrickGregoire Inner circle 3000 Posts
|
Quote:
On Sep 16, 2026, Chaz93 wrote: I never said it's not a completely normal thing. I said until it's a complete REGULAR thing for *EVERYONE*. Those are different situations. Regular meaning regularly, and everyone meaning over 80% of people. If it's still believable that some might still be using websites to look up info, it's not weird to ask someone to do so. You don't need an answer as to why you're asking them to go to a website vs use Google or AI, you just tell them to do it. And most people will do it - and it still makes sense even though that's not how they might personally do it. Could some people refuse or question why? Sure, I already mentioned that in my previous post. Though I don't ever expect that to happen. But what happens if someone refuses to fill out your billet or someone else wants you to do it to them but doesn't want to write anything down? By the way, just because I'm arguing that NameSeek can still be used and I shared a performance video of it, doesn't mean I actually use it regularly. I just use billets. |
|||||||||
|
Chaz93 Inner circle Texas 2046 Posts
|
Quote:
On Sep 16, 2026, PatrickGregoire wrote: This is where I disagree: “You don't need an answer as to why you're asking them to go to a website vs. use Google or AI; you just tell them to do it.” I think you should always account for potential points of friction when scripting and constructing your presentation. I absolutely think you do need an answer for why you're asking them to go to a website rather than simply use Google or AI, because that's a perfectly valid question for someone to ask. “Because I said so” doesn't strike me as a particularly strong response. If that approach works for you, great keep using it. I'm not saying the method is unusable. I'm saying it seems beneficial to me to think through that question ahead of time, decide how you'd answer it, and incorporate that into the scripting and presentation so that when you are invariably asked you aren't caught on the spot and having to wing it. If we're going to build a routine around a particular procedure, I think we should account for the points where a spectator might reasonably question that procedure, and then make sure our scripting eliminates that friction. If we don't plan for potential failures or objections, we're simply unprepared when they occur. This seems to be getting missed, so apologize for not being clearer with what I'm actually arguing here. Now we wait for someone to chime in with "Hey guys, new app here lets you see anything they type in their own chatgpt and reveal it!".
|
|||||||||
|
PatrickGregoire Inner circle 3000 Posts
|
“Because I said so”
Where did I say that's what you should say? I'm not trying to say you don't give them a reason, I'm saying you don't have to try and over-justify it. We've already said this - the reason to go to the site is to look up the meaning of a name. I don't believe it's necessary to justify beyond that, such as "We have to go to this site because it's much more accurate than AI". Nobody cares, they go along with what you ask of them. And in this case, it's not that weird to ask them to visit a site and use its functionality. If you disagree with that, we can agree to disagree. Btw - genuine question - have you actually gone out and performed something contextually comparable for people and asked them to visit a website for a trick and actually found that they just all use AI and Google instead of websites and brought up that it's weird, or are you just speaking from your own personal habits, and maybe some close friends'? |
|||||||||
|
Chaz93 Inner circle Texas 2046 Posts
|
As I said above, before this came out I had built my own web app that does something very, very similar. There’s a reason I don’t use it, and that’s because when you’re performing for a group, someone will inevitably be interested and start following along. They’ll type the name into Google, and then wonder why you can’t reveal the name.
If that hasn’t happened to you yet, grea but it has happened to me enough times for me to realize there is a flaw, and that’s the point I’m trying to make. And to answer your question directly: yes, of course I’ve performed something contextually comparable and paid attention to how people actually interacted with it. That’s how I learned this in the first place. I’m not basing this on my own internet habits or those of a few close friends; I’m talking about what I’ve repeatedly encountered performing for groups, particularly groups with a lot of people under 40. You may have had a different experience, and that’s perfectly possible. I’m just explaining why I reached the conclusion I did from my own performances. |
|||||||||
|
CrimeAnalyst Veteran user United States 368 Posts
|
I really like Patrick’s presentation and use of combining it with what I believe to be “Hacker”. Good combination.
I have no issue with asking a spectator to go to whatever website is necessary. Most people I encounter go to Safari/Google to type something in, as opposed to just opening up the ChatGPT app (or something similar). I’m not in a place to drop $149 on this, but if the price ever lowers I would be interested. |
|||||||||
|
PatrickGregoire Inner circle 3000 Posts
|
Quote:
On Sep 17, 2026, Chaz93 wrote: Thank you, that's important to hear, because it's not obvious (especially not when my experience hasn't at all been the same as yours). Many people talk about things without actually having done the thing they're talking about. And that wouldn't automatically invalidate their opinion, but experience does trump opinion. |
|||||||||
|
Tom Cutts Staff Northern CA 5513 Posts
|
It’s entertaining to see the guy who argued on behalf of people who might inspect a perfectly normal looking and feeling sharpie turn around and argue that a quickly becoming outdated process won’t be questioned.
That said, for people over 40 (because that seems to be the number ) it’s quick and relatively organic for a “mature” performer to say “I’m old so I still use websites… check this out, go to….” That will be effective for the next 28 days, four hours, thirty seven minutes and 12 seconds until AI completely owns all search functions.
Much as I’d like to bash the whole thing presentationally and all, that ending is a memorable image. It’s worth working out something which is far more organic to the performer and for the situation to get to that ending. Admittedly no small task to make that feel real, either. |
|||||||||
|
PatrickGregoire Inner circle 3000 Posts
|
If you're referring to me as "the guy", it's entertaining to see that people read whatever they want to read vs what someone actually wrote.
Someone had said that there would be nothing suspicious to find about the sharpie by a skeptical spectator and that it's safer in the hands of a skeptic than an impression pad. I simply pointed out that if someone were skeptical enough to question a clipboard, they might be skeptical enough to want to examine the sharpie. And if they did, they might actually find something if they did, because the sharpie actually does have something suspicious about it if you really looked. I never suggested that most people, or even anyone, would want to examine the sharpie. Moving on... |
|||||||||
|
Tom Cutts Staff Northern CA 5513 Posts
|
I can see why you’d want to attempt a forced “move on”… being that you are guilty of your own complaint.
He did not write what you have interpreted. What he did write is… Quote:
here cannot even be the background suspicion of an impression pad He quite literally did not say there was nothing to find in the Sharpie. That didn’t happen. That is your injection into his words. You have taken it a level or two beyond what is written. I will also point out that I never wrote that you “suggested that most people… would want to inspect the Sharpie”. Again, that is you injecting something which wasn’t written. What you did write is… Quote: This is your argument on behalf of those few… one.. however many who will be hyper suspicious of everything. It’s right there in your own words. Doesn’t read like someone who thinks no one “would want to examine the sharpie”.
If they're that skeptical, they will check out the sharpie and see the little camera hole, no? But I’m glad you have at least now considered that probably no one will want to examine the sharpie. |
|||||||||
| The Magic Cafe Forum Index » » Latest and Greatest? » » Nameseek by Mysterypk (28 Likes) | ||||||||||
| Go to page [Previous] 1~2 | ||||||||||
| [ Top of Page ] |
|
All content & postings Copyright © 2001-2026 Steve Brooks. All Rights Reserved. This page was created in 0.04 seconds requiring 5 database queries. |
|
The views and comments expressed on The Magic Café are not necessarily those of The Magic Café, Steve Brooks, or Steve Brooks Magic. > Privacy Statement <
![]() |