I'm unsure if this is the correct forum for this...

My wife and I are visiting Chicago in a couple of weeks just for a weekend. We have reservations at The Hand and The Eye for October 10; I plan on visiting Magic Inc as well.
What else is Chicago is a must-see? Our time is limited but I might be able to talk her into one more magic-related adventure...

Go to the Chicago Magic Lounge as well. The Hand and The Eye is awesome - very special - but also very different from the Magic Lounge. Very nice theater at the Lounge - get seats in the first couple of rows to be able to see the close-up show afterward, as it's included with tickets. Honestly, you might be a little disappointed in Magic Inc. Very different than the old one.

I recommend Chicago Magic Lounge as well. But if you'd like something more casual and intimate, I also recommend the Cosmic Underground Theater (https://cosmicundergroundtheater.com/)